Nathan Carman. The name of the 23-year-old Vermont resident, who is originally from Middletown, Connecticut, has been on the tips of everyone’s tongues since he was found safe on a life raft without his mother a week after the pair went missing during a fishing trip in September 2016. A new lawsuit by the man’s aunts alleges that he should be named the prime suspect in his mother’s presumed death and the fatal shooting of his grandfather, real estate mogul John Chakalos in 2013. Nathan denies that he killed his grandfather or harmed his mother during their fishing trip.