Judges Hear Arguments, Ask Questions on Immigration Program - NBC Connecticut
Immigration in America

Immigration in America

Full coverage of immigration issues in the U.S.

Judges Hear Arguments, Ask Questions on Immigration Program

It's the first time a federal appeals court has heard arguments on the issue



    2019 Open Enrollment Made Easy
    Reed Saxon/AP
    FILE - Demonstrators urge lawmakers to protect the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Act (DACA) outside the office of California Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein in Los Angeles, Jan. 3, 2018.

    Federal appeals court judges appeared skeptical Tuesday of the Trump administration's claim that courts don't have the power to review the president's decision to end a program that shields young immigrants from deportation.

    Lawyers for both sides spent more than an hour arguing their cases about the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program and answering questions from three judges of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Pasadena, California.

    It's the first time a federal appeals court has heard arguments on the issue. About 40 DACA supporters gathered outside the courthouse, carrying signs that said "Immigrant rights are human rights" and "Our strength stems from our roots."

    Judges focused on the administration's rationale for ending the program and whether they had authority to intervene rather than exploring the merits of allowing hundreds of thousands of young immigrants to remain in the U.S. under DACA.

    Trump on Twitter: 'DACA is Dead'

    [NATL] Trump on Twitter: 'DACA is Dead'

    President Donald Trump on Monday threatened to stop DACA bargaining and end NAFTA, tweeting "DACA is dead" and "must build a wall." Trump urged Congress to fund that wall and strengthen laws to stop what he calls "caravans" of people entering the U.S illegally. 

    (Published Monday, April 2, 2018)

    The Trump administration has said it moved to end the program last year because Texas and other states threatened to sue, raising the prospect of a chaotic end to DACA.

    Deputy Assistant Attorney General Hashim Mooppan argued Tuesday that the administration's decision could not be reviewed by courts, and he defended the move to end DACA against assertions that the decision was arbitrary and capricious.

    "It's a question of an agency saying, 'We're not going to have a policy that might well be illegal,'" Mooppan told the judges. "That is a perfectly rationale thing to do."

    The decision by Trump to end DACA prompted lawsuits across the nation, including one by the state of California.

    A judge overseeing that suit and four others challenging DACA ruled against the administration and reinstated the program that was started by then-President Barack Obama.

    The Trump administration now wants the 9th Circuit to throw out that ruling. It was not clear when the court would rule.

    Court Rejects Bid to Deny Driver's Licenses to 'Dreamers'

    [NATL] Supreme Court Rejects Bid to Deny Driver's Licenses to DACA Recipients
    The U.S. Supreme Court has rejected Arizona's plea to stop issuing drivers licenses to recipients of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. The plea comes from former Governor Jan Brewer's 2012 executive order to deny licenses to DACA recipients.
    (Published Tuesday, March 20, 2018)

    Ninth Circuit Judge Kim Wardlaw noted during the hearing that another appeals court had reviewed a similar Obama administration immigration policy.

    Judge Jacqueline Nguyen questioned whether courts could intervene if they thought DACA was legal and disagreed with the administration's position that it was unconstitutional.

    DACA has protected some 700,000 people who were brought to the U.S. illegally as children or came with families that overstayed visas.

    In January, U.S. District Judge William Alsup rejected the argument that Obama had exceeded his power in creating DACA and said the Trump administration failed to consider the disruption that ending the program would cause.

    Wardlaw seemed to agree, saying the acting Homeland Security secretary did not give "any weight" to the fact that DACA was in effect and participants were using it.

    Michael Mongan, deputy solicitor general at the California Department of Justice, told the judges the administration had to explain why it believed DACA was unlawful and faced the risk of being invalidated by a court.

    Full Version: Trump Argues With Schumer, Pelosi in Public

    [NATL] Full Version: Trump Argues With Schumer, Pelosi in Public

    President Donald Trump and Vice President Mike Pence met with Democratic Senate and House leaders Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi in the White House. Their discussion grew contentious over Trump’s demand for funding his proposed border wall.

    (Published Tuesday, Dec. 11, 2018)

    "They've got to show their homework," he said. "They haven't done that here."

    Mooppan said the administration was under no obligation to consider the fact that people had come to rely on DACA.

    Federal judges in New York and Washington, D.C., also have ruled against Trump on DACA.

    The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is expected to hear arguments this summer on an appeal of the New York judge's ruling.

    The ultimate fate of DACA likely rests in the hands of the U.S. Supreme Court.

    The administration has been critical of the 9th Circuit and took the unusual step of trying to sidestep the appeals court and have the California DACA cases heard directly by the Supreme Court.

    Trump: Payments Made Were 'A Simple Private Transaction'

    [NATL] Trump Pushes Back on Cohen Charges, Calls Payment 'Simple Private Transaction'

    President Trump is denying he told one time personal attorney and fixer Michael Cohen to pay hush money to two women who said they had affairs with Mr. Trump. The president called the payments "a simple private transaction", not a violation of campaign finance laws, which Cohen is going to jail for.

    (Published Tuesday, Dec. 11, 2018)

    The high court in February declined to do so.