Judge Declares Mistrial in Sen. Bob Menendez Bribery Case After Jury Deadlocks Twice

U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez is charged with accepting free flights on a private jet and other gifts from Florida eye doctor Salomon Melgen in exchange for political influence

What to Know

  • Sen. Menendez is accused of accepting bribes from Salomon Melgen in exchange for helping his friend with business disputes
  • Both men faced multiple fraud and bribery charges; Menendez had pleaded not guilty and denied any wrongdoing
  • A judge declared a mistrial in the case after jurors said twice they were deadlocked and could not reach a unanimous verdict on any count

The federal bribery trial of Democratic Sen. Bob Menendez ended in a mistrial Thursday when the jury said it was hopelessly deadlocked on all charges against the New Jersey politician and a wealthy donor. Prosecutors did not immediately say whether they plan to retry the lawmaker. 

U.S. District Judge William Walls declared a hung jury after more than six full days of deliberations that had to be re-started midway through when a juror was dismissed because of a pre-scheduled vacation. An alternate stepped in. 

Juror Edward Norris said that 10 of the 12 jurors wanted to acquit Menendez on all charges, but that two disagreed.

Menendez smiled and embraced his son and daughter after the second deadlock. Then, as the judge announced the mistrial, the senator looked up at the ceiling and extended his hands, his palms facing upward. 

Later, Menendez blasted investigators for bringing the case against him in the first place. He also thanked those who helped him raise millions for his legal defense fund. 

The inconclusive end to the 2½-month trial could leave the charges hanging over Menendez as he gears up for an expected run for re-election next year to the Senate, where the Republicans hold a slim edge and the Democrats need every vote they can get. 

Mike Soliman, a Menendez political adviser, reiterated that all signs point to the Demovrat running for re-election next year. Soliman said an announcement is likely in the "coming weeks." 

Menendez, 63, is accused of using his political influence to help Florida eye doctor Salomon Melgen in exchange for luxury vacations in the Caribbean and Paris, flights on Melgen's private jet and hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions to organizations that supported the senator directly or indirectly. 

Prosecutors said Menendez pressured government officials on Melgen's behalf over an $8.9 million Medicare billing dispute and a stalled contract to provide port screening equipment in the Dominican Republic, and also helped obtain U.S. visas for the doctor's girlfriends. 

The defense argued that the gifts were not bribes but tokens of friendship between two men who were "like brothers." In Menendez attorney Abbe Lowell's closing argument, he used the words "friend," ''friends" or "friendship" more than 80 times. 

Menendez's lawyers contended also that the government failed to establish a direct connection between Melgen's gifts and specific actions taken by the senator. 

Prosecutors said that didn't matter. Melgen, they said, essentially put Menendez on the payroll and made the politician his "personal senator," available as needed. 

The two men faced about a dozen counts each, including bribery, conspiracy and honest services fraud. The most serious charge against Menendez, honest services fraud, is punishable by up to 20 years in prison. He was also charged with failing to report the gifts from Melgen on his financial disclosure form. 

The jury deliberated most of last week, then restarted on Monday with an alternate after a member was excused because of a long-planned vacation. The jurors also said on Monday that they couldn't agree on a verdict, but the judge asked them to keep trying. 

This time, jury said in a note that it had reviewed all of the evidence "slowly and thoroughly and in great detail." ''We have each tried to look at this case from different viewpoints, but still feel strongly in our positions," the jurors said, adding that they were "not willing to move away from our strong convictions." 

Melgen is already facing the possibility of a long prison sentence after being convicted in April of bilking Medicare out of as much as $105 million by performing unneeded tests and treatments. 

Menendez, who has been under indictment for 2½ years, raised $2.58 million for his Senate campaign from January through September, according to federal campaign finance filings. The Republicans have a 52-48 edge in the Senate as they try to push through President Donald Trump's agenda. 

The last sitting senator convicted of a crime was Ted Stevens of Alaska, a Republican found guilty in 2008 of concealing more than $250,000 in home renovations and other gifts. His conviction was later thrown out because of prosecutorial misconduct, and he died in a 2010 plane crash. 

The Menendez case was the first major federal bribery trial since the U.S. Supreme Court in 2016 threw out the conviction of Republican former Gov. Bob McDonnell of Virginia and narrowed the definition of bribery. 

In recent months, the McDonnell ruling led judges to overturn the convictions of at least three other public officials, including a former Louisiana congressman. Menendez's lawyers had likewise hoped to get the case against the senator dismissed, but the judge refused. 

Menendez, the son of Cuban immigrants, served in the House from 1993 until he was appointed to fill a Senate vacancy in 2006. He has chaired the Foreign Relations Committee and was a major player in the unsuccessful bipartisan "Gang of Eight" effort to overhaul the nation's immigration laws in 2013. 

More recently, he drew the ire of some fellow Democrats when he opposed President Barack Obama's nuclear deal with Iran and efforts to restore diplomatic relations with Cuba.

Contact Us