UConn's Kendall Reyes scooped up a Rutgers fumble for a touchdown Saturday at Rentschler Field.
Connecticut heard all week that Rutgers would be playing Saturday for a share of the Big East championship.
Not this year.
Running back Lyle McCombs and quarterback Scott McCummings each ran for two touchdowns and the Huskies upset the Scarlet Knights 40-22, ending Rutgers' title hopes and UConn's three-game losing streak to its biggest conference rivals.
"We particularly don't like Rutgers in our locker room," said McCombs. "We weren't going to let them get a Big East title in this stadium."
Nick Williams had 158 return yards, setting up the Huskies in good field position all afternoon, and defensive tackle Kendall Reyes returned a Chas Dodd fumble for a touchdown as the Huskies forced six Rutgers turnovers.
"When we have everything going in the right way, everybody on the same page, it's scary," said linebacker Sio Moore, who forced a fumble and picked off a pass. "People are going to get hit. The quarterback's going to get hit in the mouth. We're going to cause turnovers and we're not going to stop."
Brandon Coleman had 223 receiving yards and two touchdowns for Rutgers (8-4, 4-3 Big East), which had an outside chance at a BCS bowl bid if it had won. Mohammad Sanu caught nine balls for 133 yards, extending his conference record to 109 receptions this season.
But The Huskies held Rutgers to 26 yards rushing and had six sacks, four by defensive end Trevardo Williams.
"We made a promise to ourselves as a team to stop the run game first, and take care of the rest after," Williams said.
UConn had just 290 offensive yards, but started five drives in Rutgers' territory and two others near midfield.
McCombs carried the ball 20 times for 95 yards. He now has 1,109 on the season, the fourth consecutive 1,000-yard season for a Huskies running back.
UConn (5-6, 3-3) can become bowl eligible with a win at Cincinnati next Saturday.
Rutgers freshman Gary Nova threw two fourth-quarter touchdowns to Brandon Coleman. His 17-yarder made it 40-16 and the pair hooked up on a 92-yard catch and run with 2:15 left in the game. The two-point conversion attempts failed.
Nova completed 11 of 18 passes for 298 yards, all in the fourth quarter in relief of Dodd. He was 11 of 22 for 141 yards, but he fumbled and was intercepted, and both turnovers turned into UConn touchdowns.
Williams had three kickoff returns for 128 yards, and a 30-yard punt return.
He returned the second-half kickoff 54 yards and McCombs took a handoff on the next play and ran right for 36 yards. His 4-yard run up the middle two plays later gave the Huskies a 31-10 lead.
"Anytime you come out of the locker room and make a big play, it sends a message to their sideline and your sideline," Williams said.
Williams' long punt return set up UConn's next touchdown, a 14-yard option keeper by McCummings that put the Huskies up 37-10. The extra point was blocked, giving Dave Teggart his first miss in 128 point-after attempts.
But Teggart came back to hit a 47-yard field goal after UConn ate up almost six minutes of the clock on its next possession, aided by a roughing the punter call on Rutgers.
Connecticut turned two early Rutgers turnovers into touchdowns.
UConn linebacker Sio Moore forced a fumble by Jawan Jamison on the third play of the game, giving the Huskies the ball on the Scarlet Knights' 24-yard line. UConn then handed the ball off twice to McCombs, who ran for 14 yards one first down and then went into the end zone from 10 yards out to give the Huskies a 7-0 lead.
Safety Ty-Meer Brown intercepted a pass tipped by Byron Jones on Rutgers' next drive, giving UConn the ball at the 40. McCummings ran the ball in from the 5-yard line, making a nice spin move after keeping the ball on an option play.
The Scarlet Knights put together a 13-play, 5 minute drive, but had to settle for a 25-yard San San Te field goal that cut the lead to 14-3.
A second-quarter UConn punt pinned Rutgers at its own 1-yard line. Dodd fumbled five plays later and the ball was picked up by defensive tackle Kendall Reyes, who rumbled 9 yards for the Huskies' third score and UConn's third fumble return for a TD this season.
"It was big," Reyes said. "It was basically just sitting right there and I was the closest guy to it, so I just picked it up and the end zone was just a couple of yards away."
Coleman out-jumped cornerback Blidi Wreh-Wilson for a 45-yard reception during a seven-play, 80-yard drive, which ended with a 1-yard touchdown run by Jamison with just over four minutes left in the half.
But UConn took the kickoff and drove 11 plays over the final 4:04 of the half. Teggart's 33-yard field goal gave the Huskies a 24-10 halftime lead.
McCummings ran 10 times for 47 yards and attempted just one pass for UConn, a 22-yard, one-handed completion to tight end Ryan Griffin in the second half. UConn starter Johnny McEntee was 10 of 16 for 90 yards.
The Scarlet Knights were trying to become the first team in league history to go from worst to first in consecutive seasons. The eight-win season likely will mean a trip to the Pinstripe Bowl.
"It feels like I got punched in the stomach 50 times," said Rutgers coach Greg Schiano.
UConn's loss to Louisville last week took the Huskies out of the Big East championship picture. But the Huskies are still hoping for a .500 season and a bowl bid.
Rutgers had taken five of the last six games between the two teams, including the last three by a total of nine points.